Connect with us

Forgotten Dairies

Biosecurity Must Not Become a License for Injustice -By Ardhiana Nur Suryani

Finally, require digital records of the inspections and records of custody, testing and disposal that are kept in an auditable (experiences) access-controlled manner. Use blockchain if it can bring clearly proven benefits. But technology cannot redeem an unjust application of the rule, nor transform false evidence into truth.

Published

on

Biosecurity in Poultry Farms The First Line of Defense Against  Disease

An industry can be saved by a government that throws a shipment down the drain. A government that without quasi-defensible causes, whittles it away might well be destroying a living and the public faith. Either possibility must be faced by Indonesia’s quarantine reform.

The most important final barrier to aggressive organisms threatening farms, fisheries, ecosystems and food supplies from entering the archipelago is the Indonesian Quarantine Agency (Barantin) at ports, airports and inter-island checkpoints. Its authority is indispensable. Exactly to ensure that those who fill that authority do not cause irreversible harm, signature limits must be binding.

This balance is prescribed due to Indonesia’s constitutional framework. Article 33(3) relates state control over natural resources to public prosperity; Article 28H(4) safeguards private property from arbitrary deprivation. The former must never serve as a blank check to trump the latter.

Legal basis: Law No. 21/2019 has embedded justice, science-based, necessity and notably principles of minimum impact and transparency. The difficulty lies in converting those commitments into decisions that owners can comprehend and contest before their land erodes away.

Legal precision is essential. Under Article 71, specifically designated carrier materials whose owners are not known or cannot be located, or that other agencies relinquish remain subject to inspection criteria. State control under that provision is not to be hand-waved into detention, destruction or mandatory transfer of title. Each one will need its own legal justification.

Advertisement

The hardest distributive question: loss. Owners bear destruction costs under Article 48(3), and compensation for destruction is barred under its express terms. That rule deserves to be examined with the tools of legislation: how do we separate culpable noncompliance, official error and exceptional sacrifices forced on compliant owners for the common good?

It is not safe to ship filthy goods in the name of good faith. However, public protection should neither be an excuse to escape accountability for unlawful rulings.

Indonesia needs to rein in the reigns of reform now, with Parliament and simultaneously through a series coordinated efforts between the government and Barantin.

First, define the powers precisely. Distinct and temporary custody, designation of state-control, rejection, destruction and any title transfer. Find out the responsible institution at every stage. In context also to owners, the issuance of binding timelines for officials in making successful deliveries and extendable upon providing relevant reasons regarding why they should be allowed more time.

Second: Opening up evidence so that it can be accessed and challenged. The legal basis, pertinent laboratory results, and sampling logs and rationales for uncertainty should be provided to owners. Accredited independent retesting should be undertaken, where safe and practicable. SME/Small Operators As More Than A Right Or Access? Not Barriers, Affordable Accessibility

Advertisement

Third, exercise proportionality in avoidable delay Where such alternatives can appropriately manage the risk, authorities should consider whether treatment, isolation or lawful re-export are appropriate before destruction. You might have to destroy a ticking biological weapon within the hour. They must be recorded reasons, evidence retained where it is safe to do so and the exception should encourage timely follow-up.

Fourth, set up fast independent administrative oversight that is linked to judicial review. A dedicated peer-review panel might unify the two legal and scientific. It needs to be kept from turning into a second expensive bureaucracy. If it is at all possible to safely contain destruction, then suspension of destruction should not operate automatically.

Fifth, legislate differentiated financial remedies. Settle any successful illegal action and consider separately sourcing compensation for those owners required to weather exceptional emergency losses. Pronounce on the criteria for eligibility publish, methods for valuation and safeguards against fraud.

Finally, require digital records of the inspections and records of custody, testing and disposal that are kept in an auditable (experiences) access-controlled manner. Use blockchain if it can bring clearly proven benefits. But technology cannot redeem an unjust application of the rule, nor transform false evidence into truth.

The challenge for reform is to ensure that Indonesia cannot rush through a dangerous shipment without thorough explanation, scrutiny or correction. Biosecurity protects the nation. Accountability prevents arbitrary force from abandoning protection.

Advertisement

Ardhiana Nur Suryani

Faculty of Law University 17 August 1945 Surabaya and Head of The Law Enforcement Team Indonesian Quarantine Agency

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Trending Contents

Topical Issues

Seyi-Tinubu Seyi-Tinubu
Breaking News2 days ago

Seyi Tinubu Threatens Legal Action Over Viral Statement on Father’s Presidency

Seyi Tinubu has threatened legal action against individuals behind a viral social media poster attributing a controversial statement about President...

Atiku Atiku
Breaking News2 days ago

Atiku Promises Fuel Subsidy Restoration, End to Insecurity Ahead of 2027 Election

ADC presidential candidate Atiku Abubakar promises to restore fuel and electricity subsidies, tackle insecurity and expand Kolmani oil exploration if...

Breaking News2 days ago

ADC Crisis: Nafiu Bala Seeks Reconciliation With Atiku, David Mark After Court Victory

ADC factional leader Nafiu Bala extends an olive branch to Atiku Abubakar and David Mark after a court ruling, calling...

Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan
Breaking News2 days ago

Nigeria’s Development Hindered by Primitive Leadership Recruitment, Jonathan Warns

Former President Goodluck Jonathan says Nigeria cannot progress without ending religious and ethnic bias in leadership selection and prioritising competence...

Forgotten Dairies2 days ago

Love Is Not a Substitute for a Prenuptial Agreement: The Cross-Border Financial Risks Facing Nigerians Abroad -By Daniel Nduka Okonkwo

For a cross-border prenuptial agreement to have a realistic prospect of being respected, its preparation must go beyond obtaining signatures...

Seyi Makinde and Tinubu Seyi Makinde and Tinubu
Breaking News3 days ago

Makinde: Tinubu May Be Unhappy With Me Over 2027 Presidential Ambition

Seyi Makinde says his 2027 presidential ambition may have strained his relationship with Tinubu, revealing the President has not contacted...

Ladi Adebutu Ladi Adebutu
Breaking News3 days ago

2027 Elections: Court Directs INEC to Reinstate Adebutu as Ogun PDP Governorship Candidate

Court orders INEC to publish Oladipupo Adebutu as Ogun PDP governorship candidate within 24 hours, declaring his removal unlawful and...

Breaking News3 days ago

EFCC Trial: Witness Tells Court of Presidential Orders on NSITF Activities Under Ngige

EFCC witness Onwusoro Iheamelam testifies on presidential directives and NSITF procurement activities as the trial of former minister Chris Ngige...

Amupitan SAN INEC Amupitan SAN INEC
Breaking News4 days ago

Atiku’s 2027 Ambition: INEC Will Respect Supreme Court Decision on ADC Dispute – Amupitan

Amupitan says INEC will respect Supreme Court decisions on the ADC dispute, as over 300 election-related cases remain pending ahead...

Breaking News4 days ago

Attack on NDC Meeting: Obi Still Commands Strong Support Base, Doherty Tells Politicians

Funso Doherty says Peter Obi retains significant political influence after suspected thugs attacked an NDC town hall meeting in Lagos.