Connect with us

Forgotten Dairies

Who Owns a Meme Made With AI? -By Fransiscus Nanga Roka

This is precisely why the court should require precision. What kind of image, sound text or design is claimed? What did a human do in fact? Which rights went to where and after what territories did Mementum acquire. What use of the character, if any would lead consumers to confuse the game with an authorized product in a case of trademark infringement? Even viral fame is proof of popularity but neither by itself are evidence of authorship or consumer confusion.

Published

on

AI Graphic Design Artificial Intelligence

The Indonesian creator uses generative AI to create a surreal character. Commercial rights, A french agency. The character made its way into a hit on Roblox from two American game developers. And just like that, an internet-created gag turns into a court battle in California. Who profits when AI-assisted image goes viral to the tune of millions? The answer can get quite complicated, as Spyder Games LLC v. Mementum Lab shows with one deceptively simple question.

The character, named Tung Tung Tung Sahur is a wiry, humanoid figure anthropomorphised from the viral “Italian brainrot” phenomenon. On November 26, 2025 Spyder Games and Speedy Simulator Gaming filed a lawsuit against Mementum Lab before the US District Court for the Northern District of California in connection with Steal a Brainrot. Mementum has filed counterclaims. Still the case is just a battle of the parties’ respective allegations, not a court statement that either side actually owns the character.

The developers’ issue hits at the most vulnerable point of many claims to ownership of AI: creating an image means that whoever uses this machine is not automatically the creator of everything depicted by it. According to the US Copyright Office, prompts are not enough on their own; protection will depend on whether a human exercised sufficient control over the work’s expressive elements, including via creative editing or selection. And while that rule makes all of those names, recordings, stories or subsequently human-designed works available for free commercial use; There is evidence and analysis required for each claim of works.

That would have been different danger given Mementum’s position. A trademark can be a means of identifying the source of licensed products but is not in and of itself an eternal copyright on some aspect of a popular idea. An agency should not get a monopoly on the folklore of the internet by claiming ownership and shouting us into submission that we can’t push back against. Similarly, no creator’s unique human part should be able to turn out a profitable game and take all profits while calling it “AI.”

This is precisely why the court should require precision. What kind of image, sound text or design is claimed? What did a human do in fact? Which rights went to where and after what territories did Mementum acquire. What use of the character, if any would lead consumers to confuse the game with an authorized product in a case of trademark infringement? Even viral fame is proof of popularity but neither by itself are evidence of authorship or consumer confusion.

Advertisement

Fact discovery is to end in March 2027, Judge Noël Wise ruled, along with an August hearing on case-ending and expert-evidence motions and a jury trial slated for November 8, 2027. Those are dates on the schedule—not a prediction of the decision.

Before the next meme hits the courts, game platforms and licensing agencies should take action. They must retain prompts, source files and edits along with dates of publication; delineate rights specifically for images, names, audio and any subsequent adaptations; publish clear licensing terms; and create a prompt appeal mechanism when disputed claims result in removal of content. Contracts must also specify who created the content and the revenue share of each creator.

At worst, we have introduced an across-the-board rule that all AI-assisted meme are owned by whoever registers it first—or whoever copy the idea most profitably. The better rule is less exacting and more equitable: show the human ingenuity, demonstrate the chain of rights, and establish the controversial use.

Fransiscus Nanga Roka

Faculty of Law University 17 August 1945 Surabaya and Managing Partner Law Firm Victorious Indonesia

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Trending Contents

Topical Issues

Seyi-Tinubu Seyi-Tinubu
Breaking News2 days ago

Seyi Tinubu Threatens Legal Action Over Viral Statement on Father’s Presidency

Seyi Tinubu has threatened legal action against individuals behind a viral social media poster attributing a controversial statement about President...

Atiku Atiku
Breaking News2 days ago

Atiku Promises Fuel Subsidy Restoration, End to Insecurity Ahead of 2027 Election

ADC presidential candidate Atiku Abubakar promises to restore fuel and electricity subsidies, tackle insecurity and expand Kolmani oil exploration if...

Breaking News2 days ago

ADC Crisis: Nafiu Bala Seeks Reconciliation With Atiku, David Mark After Court Victory

ADC factional leader Nafiu Bala extends an olive branch to Atiku Abubakar and David Mark after a court ruling, calling...

Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan
Breaking News2 days ago

Nigeria’s Development Hindered by Primitive Leadership Recruitment, Jonathan Warns

Former President Goodluck Jonathan says Nigeria cannot progress without ending religious and ethnic bias in leadership selection and prioritising competence...

Forgotten Dairies2 days ago

Love Is Not a Substitute for a Prenuptial Agreement: The Cross-Border Financial Risks Facing Nigerians Abroad -By Daniel Nduka Okonkwo

For a cross-border prenuptial agreement to have a realistic prospect of being respected, its preparation must go beyond obtaining signatures...

Seyi Makinde and Tinubu Seyi Makinde and Tinubu
Breaking News3 days ago

Makinde: Tinubu May Be Unhappy With Me Over 2027 Presidential Ambition

Seyi Makinde says his 2027 presidential ambition may have strained his relationship with Tinubu, revealing the President has not contacted...

Ladi Adebutu Ladi Adebutu
Breaking News3 days ago

2027 Elections: Court Directs INEC to Reinstate Adebutu as Ogun PDP Governorship Candidate

Court orders INEC to publish Oladipupo Adebutu as Ogun PDP governorship candidate within 24 hours, declaring his removal unlawful and...

Breaking News3 days ago

EFCC Trial: Witness Tells Court of Presidential Orders on NSITF Activities Under Ngige

EFCC witness Onwusoro Iheamelam testifies on presidential directives and NSITF procurement activities as the trial of former minister Chris Ngige...

Amupitan SAN INEC Amupitan SAN INEC
Breaking News4 days ago

Atiku’s 2027 Ambition: INEC Will Respect Supreme Court Decision on ADC Dispute – Amupitan

Amupitan says INEC will respect Supreme Court decisions on the ADC dispute, as over 300 election-related cases remain pending ahead...

Breaking News4 days ago

Attack on NDC Meeting: Obi Still Commands Strong Support Base, Doherty Tells Politicians

Funso Doherty says Peter Obi retains significant political influence after suspected thugs attacked an NDC town hall meeting in Lagos.