Connect with us

Forgotten Dairies

Big Food’s Legal War Against Public Health -By Fransiscus Nanga Roka

San Francisco is showing the opposite tend with legal pressure. The lawsuit accuses major manufacturers of unfair competition and public nuisance based on harmful design and marketing decisions. These are still allegations that need to be proven—none of which would make the firm actually liable as a corporation (the complaint is unhelpfully vague here). Accountability must endure scrutiny of the evidence rather than be merely a press release.

Published

on

Shoprite-Food-and-goods-warehouse-1000x600

So in court, a corporation can lose but still win years worth of sales. That is the grotesque arithmetic governments must contend with as food companies routinely battle laws intended to protect public health.

As the evidence presented here demonstrates, WHO has not filed a lawsuit as many stories suggest. Its Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus has cruelly criticized industry in litigation to impede healthy protections. In that regard, the difference is crucial: This is not a WHO prosecution of corporate law-breakers.

An investigation by Lighthouse Reports recorded 239 cases across six countries over the course of 2010-2025, with findings released in July 2026. The range of its was including nutrition policy and, in India, lawsuits challenging products by influencers. These targets were warning labels, advertisement restrictions and taxes on food or beverages. The combined proceedings totalled an impressive 595 years of litigation.

The central danger is delay. An updated warning is one that cannot help with today’s sale. Busting a suspended advertising ban does not save today’s child. A government fixated on defending one number has less bandwidth to develop the next.

And this is how what begins as judicial coercion turns into a commercial strategy: companies pocket the revenue, while public institutions are left picking up the bill for defending their own power. A final regulatory win will likely come years too late to avoid unnecessary exposure.

Advertisement

It is also perfectly legitimate for companies to contest rules that are illegal, discriminatory or poorly designed. Just because a lawsuit is filed does not mean that bad faith has been established. However, access to justice should not turn into an economic leverage where wealthy litigants wear down the institutions that protect the rest of us.

By exaggerating the science, Governments also undermine their position. Ultra-processing, nutrient composition and specific disease mechanisms are associated concepts not interchangeable findings. Britain’s Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition has highlighted associations with poor health outcomes and stressed the role of confounding along with limitations in other evidence. Good regulation rests upon crisp definitions and defensible proof.

San Francisco is showing the opposite tend with legal pressure. The lawsuit accuses major manufacturers of unfair competition and public nuisance based on harmful design and marketing decisions. These are still allegations that need to be proven—none of which would make the firm actually liable as a corporation (the complaint is unhelpfully vague here). Accountability must endure scrutiny of the evidence rather than be merely a press release.

What should governments do?

It starts with regulations designed to withstand a legal challenge; clear statutory authority, transparent nutrient criteria, objective evidence review and a documented balancing test. Imprecise drafting provides a gap for corporate lawyers to exploit

Advertisement

Second, create a co-operative legal defence fund for international cases. If governments shared pleadings, expert evidence and litigation experience, less would be lost to the unfair advantage that companies can hold from operating across jurisdictions.

Third, declare financial and non-financial support – that includes funding from industry to promote research, lobbying, and regulatory submissions. Where procedural rules allow for disclosure, courts should require a persuasive justification for corporate anonymity.

Fourth, advocate for timely resolution of population health disputes. The governing law should require balancing potential public-health harm with prior commercial injury, when deciding on interim suspension.

Lastly, have fiscal measures with action within affordable nutrition food supply, availability safe drinking water & periodical health camps in school premises. We should not be relying on purchasing power for prevention.

Reformulation does work, but voluntary commitments cannot replace enforceable standards.

Advertisement

The key question is whether governments can shield public health now and not wait for years of litigation that delivers too late. An eventual victory after years of avoidable harm, a rule on paper protected by a legal system that has failed the very people it was written to protect.

Fransiscus Nanga Roka

Faculty of Law University 17 August 1945 Surabaya and Managing Partner Law Firm Victorious Indonesia

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Trending Contents

Topical Issues

Seyi-Tinubu Seyi-Tinubu
Breaking News2 days ago

Seyi Tinubu Threatens Legal Action Over Viral Statement on Father’s Presidency

Seyi Tinubu has threatened legal action against individuals behind a viral social media poster attributing a controversial statement about President...

Atiku Atiku
Breaking News2 days ago

Atiku Promises Fuel Subsidy Restoration, End to Insecurity Ahead of 2027 Election

ADC presidential candidate Atiku Abubakar promises to restore fuel and electricity subsidies, tackle insecurity and expand Kolmani oil exploration if...

Breaking News2 days ago

ADC Crisis: Nafiu Bala Seeks Reconciliation With Atiku, David Mark After Court Victory

ADC factional leader Nafiu Bala extends an olive branch to Atiku Abubakar and David Mark after a court ruling, calling...

Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan
Breaking News2 days ago

Nigeria’s Development Hindered by Primitive Leadership Recruitment, Jonathan Warns

Former President Goodluck Jonathan says Nigeria cannot progress without ending religious and ethnic bias in leadership selection and prioritising competence...

Forgotten Dairies2 days ago

Love Is Not a Substitute for a Prenuptial Agreement: The Cross-Border Financial Risks Facing Nigerians Abroad -By Daniel Nduka Okonkwo

For a cross-border prenuptial agreement to have a realistic prospect of being respected, its preparation must go beyond obtaining signatures...

Seyi Makinde and Tinubu Seyi Makinde and Tinubu
Breaking News4 days ago

Makinde: Tinubu May Be Unhappy With Me Over 2027 Presidential Ambition

Seyi Makinde says his 2027 presidential ambition may have strained his relationship with Tinubu, revealing the President has not contacted...

Ladi Adebutu Ladi Adebutu
Breaking News4 days ago

2027 Elections: Court Directs INEC to Reinstate Adebutu as Ogun PDP Governorship Candidate

Court orders INEC to publish Oladipupo Adebutu as Ogun PDP governorship candidate within 24 hours, declaring his removal unlawful and...

Breaking News4 days ago

EFCC Trial: Witness Tells Court of Presidential Orders on NSITF Activities Under Ngige

EFCC witness Onwusoro Iheamelam testifies on presidential directives and NSITF procurement activities as the trial of former minister Chris Ngige...

Amupitan SAN INEC Amupitan SAN INEC
Breaking News4 days ago

Atiku’s 2027 Ambition: INEC Will Respect Supreme Court Decision on ADC Dispute – Amupitan

Amupitan says INEC will respect Supreme Court decisions on the ADC dispute, as over 300 election-related cases remain pending ahead...

Breaking News4 days ago

Attack on NDC Meeting: Obi Still Commands Strong Support Base, Doherty Tells Politicians

Funso Doherty says Peter Obi retains significant political influence after suspected thugs attacked an NDC town hall meeting in Lagos.