Connect with us

Forgotten Dairies

South Korea’s Medical Liability Crisis -By Fransiscus Nanga Roka

Herein lies the danger paradox: The more society asks for perfect outcomes, the less likely it is to actually find doctors who will perform in specialties that have the greatest likelihood of failure. How does that protect patients? It abandons them.

Published

on

South Korea

The brutal truth is that a healthcare system cannot be sustained when the most important people needed to save lives are also ones most vulnerable to destruction. What is going on is more than a staffing issue, it is a collapse of the fabric of trust in high risk clinical science. The why it matters is obvious: patients lose access sooner than they lose treatment, when pediatricians, surgeons, obstetricians and emergency doctors live in fear of lawsuits over sickness.

That puts you in a place where the target is on Who. Doctors, hospitals, families, insurers and the government. The immediate casualties are the frontline specialists burdened with soaring malpractice premiums, aggressive lawsuits and ever-present risks that one bad outcome could lead to civil or criminal liability. The collateral damage will fall on regular citizens reliant on vital services that are becoming even more challenging to man. Where is this unfolding? In hospitals as high-risk specialties become less appealing among young physicians in South Korea. WHEN did the crisis become impossible to deny? When legal exposure and insurance costs had risen so much that they distorted the choice of specialty and impaired needed care capacity. How has the government responded? To stabilize the workforce, the government should intervene through the Ministry of Health and Welfare: fully covering liability premiums for high-risk specialties.

That intervention is necessary. But it is also an indictment.

There is no need for a country to subsidize fear in order to keep pediatric wards running and operating rooms resourced. If by charging 100% of malpractice premiums for these specialists places a financial burden on the state, then the insurance pricing is not the only issue. This is one of the environment that has created medical risk intolerable as it is a legal and institutional framework Bad outcomes in South Korea have become too often regarded as events deserving punishment within a system that has found itself entrenched, in spite of the uncertainty, difficulty and imperfections that are inherent in medicine.

Herein lies the danger paradox: The more society asks for perfect outcomes, the less likely it is to actually find doctors who will perform in specialties that have the greatest likelihood of failure. How does that protect patients? It abandons them.

Advertisement

It earns marks for being straightforward. For example, the government lowers the burden of the doctors in pediatrics, obstetrics, surgery, thoracic and cardiovascular surgery and emergency medicine by fully covering premiums It also protects hospitals from the unexpected catastrophe claims, and can even help restore some of the confidence among younger doctors that have been shying away from the core important specialties. This should buy some time and in the meantime keep the critical services from getting to a wider fall-out crisis.

But subsidy, in itself, is not strategy.

Your solution should be structural at probably a deeper level. The first step is that malpractice handling in South Korea should clearly distinguish between gross negligence and honest adverse outcome. A fourth is to use a more prompt, less adversarial and less financially punishing method of settling medical disputes nationwide. Third, compensation rules must be reengineered to ensure patient safety, without making every complication a career catastrophe. Fourth, work force incentives in the long-term and permanent setting for areas of high risk rather than crisis subsidies. Fifth, we need to improve medical education and health systems so that fewer doctors practice defensive medicine under enormous duress.

Policy, only, does, buy time; returns impending crisis. When fear itself is a target of reform, the system can regenerate.

South Korea does not just write the check for insurance premiums It is the cost of a legal culture that has driven essential medicine to the brink. The question is, does such an intervention become a bridge to reform or simply a taxpayer funded bailout of a dysfunctional system.

Advertisement

Fransiscus Nanga Roka

Faculty of Law University 17 August 1945 Surabaya and Managing Partner Law Firm Victorious Indonesia

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Trending Contents

Topical Issues

Seyi-Tinubu Seyi-Tinubu
Breaking News2 days ago

Seyi Tinubu Threatens Legal Action Over Viral Statement on Father’s Presidency

Seyi Tinubu has threatened legal action against individuals behind a viral social media poster attributing a controversial statement about President...

Atiku Atiku
Breaking News2 days ago

Atiku Promises Fuel Subsidy Restoration, End to Insecurity Ahead of 2027 Election

ADC presidential candidate Atiku Abubakar promises to restore fuel and electricity subsidies, tackle insecurity and expand Kolmani oil exploration if...

Breaking News2 days ago

ADC Crisis: Nafiu Bala Seeks Reconciliation With Atiku, David Mark After Court Victory

ADC factional leader Nafiu Bala extends an olive branch to Atiku Abubakar and David Mark after a court ruling, calling...

Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan
Breaking News2 days ago

Nigeria’s Development Hindered by Primitive Leadership Recruitment, Jonathan Warns

Former President Goodluck Jonathan says Nigeria cannot progress without ending religious and ethnic bias in leadership selection and prioritising competence...

Forgotten Dairies2 days ago

Love Is Not a Substitute for a Prenuptial Agreement: The Cross-Border Financial Risks Facing Nigerians Abroad -By Daniel Nduka Okonkwo

For a cross-border prenuptial agreement to have a realistic prospect of being respected, its preparation must go beyond obtaining signatures...

Seyi Makinde and Tinubu Seyi Makinde and Tinubu
Breaking News4 days ago

Makinde: Tinubu May Be Unhappy With Me Over 2027 Presidential Ambition

Seyi Makinde says his 2027 presidential ambition may have strained his relationship with Tinubu, revealing the President has not contacted...

Ladi Adebutu Ladi Adebutu
Breaking News4 days ago

2027 Elections: Court Directs INEC to Reinstate Adebutu as Ogun PDP Governorship Candidate

Court orders INEC to publish Oladipupo Adebutu as Ogun PDP governorship candidate within 24 hours, declaring his removal unlawful and...

Breaking News4 days ago

EFCC Trial: Witness Tells Court of Presidential Orders on NSITF Activities Under Ngige

EFCC witness Onwusoro Iheamelam testifies on presidential directives and NSITF procurement activities as the trial of former minister Chris Ngige...

Amupitan SAN INEC Amupitan SAN INEC
Breaking News4 days ago

Atiku’s 2027 Ambition: INEC Will Respect Supreme Court Decision on ADC Dispute – Amupitan

Amupitan says INEC will respect Supreme Court decisions on the ADC dispute, as over 300 election-related cases remain pending ahead...

Breaking News4 days ago

Attack on NDC Meeting: Obi Still Commands Strong Support Base, Doherty Tells Politicians

Funso Doherty says Peter Obi retains significant political influence after suspected thugs attacked an NDC town hall meeting in Lagos.