Connect with us

Forgotten Dairies

Samarco: Safety Cannot Follow the Bulldozers, by Fransiscus Nanga Roka

As courts and regulators can say “stop” where evidence is not complete, the decisive test. The latter is precaution made as a promise to the living and justified only after the fact to the dead.

Published

on

Fransiscus Nanga Roka - Indonesia

The harsh question Brazil is grappling with is: do communities have to suffer through yet another mining disaster before precaution can be mandated?

In Minas Gerais, Instituto Cordilheira is contesting an appellate provisional ruling on Samarco Long Term Plan. Community advocates, bolstered by ELAW’s technical expertise and partner organizations, are pressing for more rigorous environmental and human rights protections before a proposed expansion to allow the extraction of iron ore and new tailings storage facilities. (Reporting by Clara Ferreira Marques; Editing by Louise Heavens and David Clarke) (The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.) Vale and BHP each own half of Samarco.

The historical warning is devastating. The Fundão dam at the Germano Complex operated by Samarco collapsed, in Mariana, killing 19 people on November 5th, 2015. And that history does not dictate that all future endeavors must fall short. This does render scrupulous examination essential.

ELAW reports that on April 24, 2026, an injunction issued in December halted installation work pending further climate studies. The court recognized shortcomings in the environmental assessment and required predictive hydrological and geotechnical modeling, emissions assessment as well as adaptation measures over the entire period of operation and post-closure. But the climate-study requirement was kept in an appellate ruling, so work didn’t go ahead and the appeal came.

And that procedural compromise should be looked at very harshly. Why allow construction to move forward, before the studies can help characterize material risks?

Advertisement

And it is a danger that is as much institutional as engineering. As capital is locked in, structures climb up, contracts cascade and pressure mounts on authorities to open the floodgates for what has already risen. The sunk cost shadow can turn environmental review into a form of ceremony.

A post-hoc study could document risk without actually averting it when consequential construction decisions are made.

More than just some comforting words did so as the planet demands resilience against climate change. Plausible future extremes, compounded hazards and long-term maintenance failures must all be compared to tailings infrastructure. Tomorrow’s question of safety cannot be answered by historical rainfall records alone. Equally, a tech label should not be a replacement for what has been tested to really work.

Five Strategic Safeguards Brazil Needs to Adopt.

Disruption risk assessment should begin by abrogating works that may will undermine the quality of meaningful evaluations during this interim period, until the absent studies can be subjected to impartial scrutiny. Restrictions should be commensurate with the risks, and the reversibility of specific activities, together with transparent test conditions required to restart.

Advertisement

Second, regulators would encourage disclosure of modeling assumptions, ranges of uncertainty and background data and plausible (not just extreme) failure scenarios. Communities require funded access to independent experts and a meaningful chance to interrogate the evidence.

Third, licensing should assess other technically feasible alternatives such as reduced expansion and no expansion. A process that asks only how to build has already given up the question of whether to build.

Fourth, enforceable financial guarantees for emergency response, environmental restoration and closure and post-closure monitoring should be provided by Samarco and its shareholders. Such proposed guarantees should be robust enough to survive corporate insolvency and restructuring. Any obligation in future safety must be kept separate from compensation for past harm.

Fifth, people who are impacted should co-design monitoring and emergency plans. Thresholds for public performance, warning systems accessible to the whole community and suspension triggers prior to professional events would make participation active protection.

The lesson for Vale, BHP and international investors extends beyond Brazil: they need to prove their environmental credibility before creating extra exposure.

Advertisement

Communities should not have to shoulder the burden of rebutting corporate assurances, while construction constrains their options.

As courts and regulators can say “stop” where evidence is not complete, the decisive test. The latter is precaution made as a promise to the living and justified only after the fact to the dead.

Fransiscus Nanga Roka

Faculty of Law University 17 August 1945 Surabaya and Managing Partner Law Firm Victorious Indonesia

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Trending Contents

Topical Issues

quality-nigerian-flag-for-sale-in-lagos quality-nigerian-flag-for-sale-in-lagos
Breaking News2 days ago

Nigeria, Russia Strengthen Customs Ties with New Trade Cooperation Agreement

The Nigeria Customs Service and Russia's Federal Customs Service agree to deepen trade cooperation, exchange intelligence and improve cargo movement.

Jeff Okoroafor new photo Jeff Okoroafor new photo
Politics2 days ago

Soludo’s Billboard Crackdown: Fear, Not Law, In Anambra -By Jeff Okoroafor

These actions constitute a fundamental betrayal of democratic principles. As the Coalition of South East Youth Leaders (COSEYL) rightly noted,...

Breaking News2 days ago

Peter Obi’s Image Not Reason Umeh’s Billboard Was Removed, Anambra Govt Insists

Anambra Government denies removing Victor Umeh's billboard because it featured Peter Obi, citing alleged non-compliance with signage laws.

Tinubu and Soludo Tinubu and Soludo
Breaking News2 days ago

2027: Soludo Predicts Tinubu’s Victory, Says President Has No Need to Rig Election

Chukwuma Soludo predicts Tinubu's victory in 2027, claiming the APC has stronger nationwide support and no credible opposition alternative.

Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan
Breaking News2 days ago

Jonathan Reveals Why He Had No Problem Handing Over Power to Buhari

Goodluck Jonathan reveals why handing over power to late President Muhammadu Buhari was easy, describing him as a statesman who...

Adams Oshiomhole Adams Oshiomhole
Breaking News2 days ago

2027: Oshiomhole Insists Igbo President Must Serve Eight Years, Rejects ‘Half Cup’

Senator Adams Oshiomhole says the South-East must not accept a truncated presidential tenure, insisting an Igbo president deserves eight full...

Legal law gavel Legal law gavel
Breaking News3 days ago

N22m Hilux Theft: Bayelsa Court Jails 39-Year-Old Driver for Five Years

Perelayefa Nelson has been jailed for five years after a Bayelsa court convicted him over his involvement in the disappearance...

Uba Sani Uba Sani
Breaking News3 days ago

‘We Have All Failed the People’: Uba Sani Challenges Northern Leaders to Account for Region’s Decline

Uba Sani challenges past and present northern leaders to embrace accountability, reject ethnic politics and develop a common agenda ahead...

European Commission European Commission
Breaking News3 days ago

Ukraine: EU Seeks €45bn Loan as Russian War Deepens Kyiv’s Budget Crisis

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen says a proposed €45bn loan would strengthen Ukraine’s position at the negotiation table.

Abaribe Abaribe
Breaking News3 days ago

Abaribe Laments Leadership Deficit in Nigeria, Says Country Needs Azikiwe’s Vision

At the 14th Zik Lecture Series, Abaribe praises Azikiwe's leadership philosophy and calls for purposeful governance in Nigeria.