Connect with us

Global Issues

Germany’s Gaza Liability Test Cannot Die on Procedure -By Fransiscus Nanga Roka

Buried behind procedural technicalities, this will be a ruthless message: international law binds the hand triggering the gun but not the hefty hand supplying it.

Published

on

Iran-Gaza-Hamas-Israel-missile-attack

On the morning of September 7, Germany walked into the Peace Palace to ask judges to terminate Nicaragua v. Germany before being forced to confront the moral gut: can a state allow an ally to use its weapons if those weapons could enable genocide or crimes against humanity?

Germany’s preliminary objections are being heard at the International Court of Justice from now until September 10. Berlin contends that (i) the Court lacks jurisdiction, (ii) Nicaragua did not demonstrate it was an existing bilateral dispute existed at the time the case was filed, and (iii) because Israel is absent from these proceedings a ruling cannot be rendered as to Israel’s conduct.

That’s a serious interstate layer of what amounts to procedural defense. But procedure must not devolve into diplomatic body armor.

The case was brought by Nicaragua in March 2024 against Germany, Israel’s second-largest arms supplier at the outbreak of hostilities for breaching the Genocide Convention, Geneva Conventions and customary international law through the provision of military materials to Israel, political support for Israel and withholding financial assistance to UNRWA. Germany denies the allegations, insisting that its export controls are beyond international standards.

Even though Nicaragua has not been injured on the battlefield, it relies on the duties owed to all parties to the Genocide Convention. This is Germany’s own claimed failure not to prevent genocide and/or crimes against humanity, but not Germany’s criminal guilt; and not merely about Israel’s conduct. The origins of the dispute date back to 2024 and it returned to The Hague in September 2026. Because arms-exporting states cannot uphold the imperatives of military action when they treat weapons licences as neutral legal documents. By persisting in providing assistance despite being aware of credible intelligence indicating that supplied matériel might facilitate prohibited acts.

Advertisement

Provisional measures were not ordered by the Court, however: 19 April 2024 It didn’t acquit Germany nor dismiss Nicaragua’s case. The Court rather highlighted that states providing arms must refrain from transfers which can be used in violation of international law.

The “something” problem in Germany’s case, the claim to be the “indispensable third party” threatens to carve out a deadly exclusionary zone: when the original alleged perpetrator is outside of the Court’s reach, every facilitating state could become as unreachable. All international responsibility would then be folded into a jurisdictional triangle.

We are all well aware of Nicaragua’s own authoritarian track record, but it does not negate the question of law. The very existence of erga omnes partes obligations is exactly because prevention cannot rely on the geopolitical qualification of the applicant. But Nicaragua still has to demonstrate jurisdiction, a prior dispute and a breach with some seizable legal basis; outrage doesn’t substitute for evidence.

The ICJ should retain claims that are justiciable by analyzing Germany’s actions, and only dismiss isclaims requiring deciding on Israel’s legal culpability in its absence. It should define the knowledge, foreseeability and due-diligence standards for arms transfers under the duty to prevent genocide and Common Article 1 of the Geneva Conventions.

Germany, in the meantime, should immediately suspend licenses that there are serious humanitarian risks involved with and produce assessments on a weapon-by-weapon basis. Other exporting states must implement similar safeguards to those in the new law and permit opacity regarding licensing decisions to judicial review.

Advertisement

Buried behind procedural technicalities, this will be a ruthless message: international law binds the hand triggering the gun but not the hefty hand supplying it.

Fransiscus Nanga Roka

Faculty of Law University 17 August 1945 Surabaya and Managing Partner Law Firm Victorious Indonesia

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Trending Contents

Topical Issues

Senator Jim Nwobodo and Peter Mbah Senator Jim Nwobodo and Peter Mbah
Breaking News2 days ago

Enugu Govt Moves to Rename ESUT in Honour of Founder Jim Nwobodo

Governor Peter Mbah of Enugu State has expressed support for renaming the Enugu State University of Science and Technology (ESUT)...

quality-nigerian-flag-for-sale-in-lagos quality-nigerian-flag-for-sale-in-lagos
Breaking News2 days ago

Nigeria, Russia Strengthen Customs Ties with New Trade Cooperation Agreement

The Nigeria Customs Service and Russia's Federal Customs Service agree to deepen trade cooperation, exchange intelligence and improve cargo movement.

Jeff Okoroafor new photo Jeff Okoroafor new photo
Politics2 days ago

Soludo’s Billboard Crackdown: Fear, Not Law, In Anambra -By Jeff Okoroafor

These actions constitute a fundamental betrayal of democratic principles. As the Coalition of South East Youth Leaders (COSEYL) rightly noted,...

Breaking News2 days ago

Peter Obi’s Image Not Reason Umeh’s Billboard Was Removed, Anambra Govt Insists

Anambra Government denies removing Victor Umeh's billboard because it featured Peter Obi, citing alleged non-compliance with signage laws.

Tinubu and Soludo Tinubu and Soludo
Breaking News3 days ago

2027: Soludo Predicts Tinubu’s Victory, Says President Has No Need to Rig Election

Chukwuma Soludo predicts Tinubu's victory in 2027, claiming the APC has stronger nationwide support and no credible opposition alternative.

Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan
Breaking News3 days ago

Jonathan Reveals Why He Had No Problem Handing Over Power to Buhari

Goodluck Jonathan reveals why handing over power to late President Muhammadu Buhari was easy, describing him as a statesman who...

Adams Oshiomhole Adams Oshiomhole
Breaking News3 days ago

2027: Oshiomhole Insists Igbo President Must Serve Eight Years, Rejects ‘Half Cup’

Senator Adams Oshiomhole says the South-East must not accept a truncated presidential tenure, insisting an Igbo president deserves eight full...

Legal law gavel Legal law gavel
Breaking News3 days ago

N22m Hilux Theft: Bayelsa Court Jails 39-Year-Old Driver for Five Years

Perelayefa Nelson has been jailed for five years after a Bayelsa court convicted him over his involvement in the disappearance...

Uba Sani Uba Sani
Breaking News3 days ago

‘We Have All Failed the People’: Uba Sani Challenges Northern Leaders to Account for Region’s Decline

Uba Sani challenges past and present northern leaders to embrace accountability, reject ethnic politics and develop a common agenda ahead...

European Commission European Commission
Breaking News3 days ago

Ukraine: EU Seeks €45bn Loan as Russian War Deepens Kyiv’s Budget Crisis

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen says a proposed €45bn loan would strengthen Ukraine’s position at the negotiation table.