Connect with us

Forgotten Dairies

Indonesia’s Rule of Law Crisis: An Invalid Audit, Extreme Sentencing Demands, and the Erosion of Fair Trial Guarantees -By Fransiscus Nanga Roka

That is how rule of law crises in fact solidify. Constitutions do not vanish for official parlance always remains the language of justice while imbibing its contents. Asking the public to accept severe punishment based on evidence that is subject to debate does not bolster rule of law. It is examining the depth of illegitimacy that Citizens will put up with before calling it out for what it has become, not justice.

Published

on

Prabowo-Subianto-President-Indonesia-2024

At times a legal case becomes less about prosecution and more about indictment. Indonesia is now a fa­ciating line about that. When the audit that was used to justify staggeringly huge claims of state loss is condemned as methodologically invalid, and yet prosecutors continue pressing for crushing punishment regardless, treating this like any other prosecution or case scandal then it can no longer be about one defendant one courtroom or even one minor scandal. The question becomes if the rule of law still means restraint or has been turned into a slogan recited while power acts as it wants.

The character of a justice system is best revealed not when it punishes the guilty but rather, where punishment earns credibility based on processes that inspire public confidence. That is the crux of the crisis. Once, however exposure destroys the evidentiary backbone of a case every demand build on it becomes morally unstable. And when the state is still demanding harsh sentencing, gargantuan damages and hefty fines on an already contested foundation well it doesn’t look firm. It looks reckless.

This is what ought to frighten Malaysia’s democratic partners and anyone including the United Nations who believes that due process, despite its recent parlance as an empty phrase. Fair trial guarantees are not mere technicalities to be ignored when a case serves political goals, advances agendas or proves emotionally satisfying. They are the final line of defense against legal accountability and state-backed collectivised coercion. When courts permit the government to pursue such life destroying consequences based on calculations that have been thoroughly exposed as far from credible, courtroom becomes a machine for rubberstamping predetermined punishment instead of an arena in which evidence is weighed and truth tested.

Again this is not a legal abstraction. It is a civic emergency. For when prosecutors act as if methodological collapse requires no institutional humility, they send a message well beyond the case at hand. They tell the populace that when the narrative of state has been set, then a contrary expert can be safely disregarded; fairness in procedures can be dispensed with as an inconvenience too cumbersome to remove, and lawfulness examined through a lens where proportionality is weakness. Under such circumstances, power no longer gets shamed by law. Power disciplines law.

What is most disturbing about such a controversy has nothing to do with the potential for error. Errors happen in every system. The real story is institutional recalcitrance grappling with credible opposition. A solemn legal command,* however, knows when to halt for a moment and re-evaluate: that dubious evidence cannot bear the burden of punishment as severe alter life. A frightened legal order, on the other hand is one that does just this: it escalates and hardens; it confuses aggression with legitimacy. It perceives obstinacy for strength. Actually, that is not confidence. It is panic wearing a robe.

Advertisement

Advocates of maximal prosecution often hide behind a familiar moral cudgel: corruption is bad, the state has to be tough. Except this argument falls apart as soon as process becomes of no importance. It is not IN justice purified by lack of evidentiary rigor. It is power unrestrained. The war on corruption only becomes valid if it is stricter actually visibly tighter than its quality in normal politics, not loosened just because public anger lets one take short cuts more easily. If extreme sanctions can remain underwritten even by weak or disputed methodology, the anti-corruption banner threatens to become as much a cover for sovereign abuse of law.

Which is precisely why this controversy has ramifications that extend beyond the borders of Indonesia. You are the unpredictable rule that courts watch investors. They observe whether institutions are fair, which is aided by civil society. You monitor in the international community to see if your constitutional pledges stand firm under public pressure. Now, a country is not sapping its credibility when criticism flows; it overly weakens credibility. See Russia in Ukraine! gobbling countries that go along because too scared to challenge WHO with transparent proof instead of leaping lizards at every identifiable wealthier nation else badging them for rejection.

And let no one kid themselves: a demand for an extreme sentence is not just another line in a court filing. It is the state taking away a human life years. A crime that can ruin homes, livelihoods, reputations and confidence in our institutions. It follows that the moral threshold for raising such a demand must be high. In short, if the state finds itself on a foundation which is already being subjected to severe methodological attack and then it exceeds that threshold as well then this is not just a hard case. To be sure, it is a warning bell for the health of justice itself.

Normalization is the worst threat at that moment. Now, methodological objections are simply technicalities so the public is led to believe first. Then fairness concerns are golden shields for clever defenses. It is then said here that severity demonstrates seriousness. Finally, punishment itself replaces evidence. The more loud and awful the sentences are, the less likely anyone is to ask if they were correct by any standards. That is how due process dies in modern democracies, not by dramatic repeal of the rulebook but with a public trained to see that procedure matters only so long as it remains convenient for power.

Indonesia deserves better than that. A constitutional democracy should be embarrassing when the standards of proof are questioned. It must learn that legitimacy is not earned by harder insisting, but better proving. That is not weakness, and it should be aware of that. It is the most elementary stage of becoming legally mature. No prosecution, however much prestige or outrage or political momentum surrounds it, should be above scrutiny that even low-functioning legal brain cells would find a match for.

Advertisement

Though the outcome of one prosecution might seem a small thing, this is about more than just that. Where Indonesia enables capital punishment in the wake of a sham, or extremely questionable audit, that harm won’t conclude through one decision. The wound will be deeper: the institutional backdrop. It teaches citizens that fairness is a negotiable thing. A lesson in unstable arithmetic, that observers will learn is accountability. And future prosecutors will absorb the most pernicious lesson of all, that once the wheels for punishment start turning, evidentiary frailty is only an optics issue.

That is how rule of law crises in fact solidify. Constitutions do not vanish for official parlance always remains the language of justice while imbibing its contents. Asking the public to accept severe punishment based on evidence that is subject to debate does not bolster rule of law. It is examining the depth of illegitimacy that Citizens will put up with before calling it out for what it has become, not justice.

If this case really comes down to a flawed audit while still facing exceptional punishment, Indonesia faces the kind of choice that no democracy should ever make lightly. It can reaffirm that the guarantees of a fair trial are not just words on paper, that evidence matters more than prosecutorial vanity and pride, that state power should step back when it uproots its own foundations. Or it can go hack onto a road where punishment is primary, justification secondary and legitimacy is little more than performance art.

Such a nation could still have courts, prosecutors and judicial discourse. Yet it will have lost something much more fundamental: the moral authority to require belief in its decisions by the public.

A state that pursues such severe penalty on the basis of compromised evidence is not defending justice. It is marketing how simply due process can be abandoned by houses which are eager to win rather than establish facts.

Advertisement

Fransiscus Nanga Roka

Faculty of Law University 17 August 1945 Surabaya Indonesia

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Trending Contents

Topical Issues

quality-nigerian-flag-for-sale-in-lagos quality-nigerian-flag-for-sale-in-lagos
Breaking News2 days ago

Nigeria, Russia Strengthen Customs Ties with New Trade Cooperation Agreement

The Nigeria Customs Service and Russia's Federal Customs Service agree to deepen trade cooperation, exchange intelligence and improve cargo movement.

Jeff Okoroafor new photo Jeff Okoroafor new photo
Politics2 days ago

Soludo’s Billboard Crackdown: Fear, Not Law, In Anambra -By Jeff Okoroafor

These actions constitute a fundamental betrayal of democratic principles. As the Coalition of South East Youth Leaders (COSEYL) rightly noted,...

Breaking News2 days ago

Peter Obi’s Image Not Reason Umeh’s Billboard Was Removed, Anambra Govt Insists

Anambra Government denies removing Victor Umeh's billboard because it featured Peter Obi, citing alleged non-compliance with signage laws.

Tinubu and Soludo Tinubu and Soludo
Breaking News2 days ago

2027: Soludo Predicts Tinubu’s Victory, Says President Has No Need to Rig Election

Chukwuma Soludo predicts Tinubu's victory in 2027, claiming the APC has stronger nationwide support and no credible opposition alternative.

Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan Ex-President-Goodluck-Jonathan
Breaking News2 days ago

Jonathan Reveals Why He Had No Problem Handing Over Power to Buhari

Goodluck Jonathan reveals why handing over power to late President Muhammadu Buhari was easy, describing him as a statesman who...

Adams Oshiomhole Adams Oshiomhole
Breaking News2 days ago

2027: Oshiomhole Insists Igbo President Must Serve Eight Years, Rejects ‘Half Cup’

Senator Adams Oshiomhole says the South-East must not accept a truncated presidential tenure, insisting an Igbo president deserves eight full...

Legal law gavel Legal law gavel
Breaking News3 days ago

N22m Hilux Theft: Bayelsa Court Jails 39-Year-Old Driver for Five Years

Perelayefa Nelson has been jailed for five years after a Bayelsa court convicted him over his involvement in the disappearance...

Uba Sani Uba Sani
Breaking News3 days ago

‘We Have All Failed the People’: Uba Sani Challenges Northern Leaders to Account for Region’s Decline

Uba Sani challenges past and present northern leaders to embrace accountability, reject ethnic politics and develop a common agenda ahead...

European Commission European Commission
Breaking News3 days ago

Ukraine: EU Seeks €45bn Loan as Russian War Deepens Kyiv’s Budget Crisis

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen says a proposed €45bn loan would strengthen Ukraine’s position at the negotiation table.

Abaribe Abaribe
Breaking News3 days ago

Abaribe Laments Leadership Deficit in Nigeria, Says Country Needs Azikiwe’s Vision

At the 14th Zik Lecture Series, Abaribe praises Azikiwe's leadership philosophy and calls for purposeful governance in Nigeria.